The Emotions Behind Elvis Presley’s “Blue Christmas” [25 Days of Holiday Songs]

Thank you to all who have read the posts for the “25 Days of Holiday Songs” Challenge”. I am so thrilled that everyone has been enjoying them! Melanie, author of the blog Melanie at Home, writes today’s post about a modern Christmas classic from one of the most influential singers of the latter half of the 20th Century. Enjoy!

“Let’s just get this over with.”

These words, according to backup singer Millie Kirkham, were uttered by Elvis Presley before he recorded his epochal Christmas hit. Elvis hadn’t wanted to record this tune (originated by Doye O’Dell in 1948) and had instructed his backup group, the Jordanaires, to “do something silly” in the background. [1]

When Elvis recorded the song in September 1957, he was worn out.  He had bought Graceland earlier that year (paying $1,000 as a down payment on the home) but had barely spent time in it. Elvis was getting into silly confrontations (like when Elvis pulled a toy gun on a Marine during a fight). He left his high school girlfriend Barbara Hearn behind as he embarked on a series of flirtations with starlets and underage fans.

Presley’s grueling 1956 touring schedule had pivoted into an exhausting filming schedule, and he just wasn’t feeling the song, written by Billy Hayes and Jay W. Johnson. But his upcoming Christmas album needed some filler, so the tune went onto wax.

The song would not be released as a single until 1964, and when it was, it was an instant classic. In the UK it was the B-Side to “White Christmas” (so colorful!) and shot up the chart to number 11. The mournful tale of unrequited love wold go on to be covered by The Beach Boys, Ringo Starr, and many more.

For me, “Blue Christmas” evokes not only unrequited love but also grief. The first holiday after you lose someone is so difficult–putting up the tree and baking cookies happen on autopilot. “[It] won’t be the same, dear, if you’re not here with me” succinctly describes Christmas 2016 for me.

It is incredible to me how much emotion is in this song, despite Presley’s choppy vocal and instruction to the Jordanaires to get silly. “Blue Christmas” stands the test of time as a tender love song, perfect for getting lost in your memories as you stare at the tree with misty eyes.

You can check this song out on my “25 Days of Holiday Songs” playlist featured on Spotify.



40 thoughts on “The Emotions Behind Elvis Presley’s “Blue Christmas” [25 Days of Holiday Songs]

  1. Melanie,

    I liked reading the backstory on this classic Elvis Christmas song. While it’s not one of my favorites I so enjoy including it during the holidays. It’s a bit too sad for me. ‘Blue Christmas’ is always a part of my life since the passing of my brother in 2006 & this year I’m sure DH & I will find our thoughts on his parents who are no longer with us. His 95-year-old dad passed in March.

  2. Alayna Frankenberry says:

    Honestly I like this song more than most holiday songs. It does bum me out, but not as much as hearing Mariah for the 100th time.

  3. I have a confession to make Christmas time is super hard for me and especially Xmas music. I don’t know why but it is (Well I do know but …another topic). I love ELVIS so now I may just give this another go. Maybe.
    Thank you for the post I would have never ever known.

  4. Jareds_mum says:

    I am not familiar with this Christmas song probably because my father was not much of an Elvis fan that I did not grow up listening to it. It sure is an interesting song but maybe just a bit too sappy for Christmas.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.